Denver Voters Don't Support Columbus Day Protest Goals

Analysis by Floyd Ciruli
January 7, 2008

The goal of Columbus Day protestors is to stop the celebration.  The leader of the protesters, Metro State Professor Glenn Morris, believes the annual arrest of protesters will sway public opinion against the celebration.  After several years of high-profile effort, polls show he is wrong.  Most voters do not want to ban the celebration nor accept his claim it is racist.

Rather, a survey of Denver voters conducted in October 2007 shows a majority of voters believe Columbus Day “participants have a right to march in the parade” and do not believe the event should be disbanded.

Three-quarters (74%) agree with the statement: “Columbus Day should continue to be celebrated as it is now.”  One-half of Denver voters strongly agree with the position.  Seventy-two percent reject that the parade is a racist event and should be ended (54% strongly disagree the event is racist and should end).

Denver Voters and Columbus Day Protests
Statements	Total Agree	Strongly Agree	Strongly Disagree	Total Disagree	Don’t Know
Columbus Day should continue to be celebrated as it is now.  The participants have a right to march in the parade	74%	50%	10%	20%	5%
Columbus Day is a racist event and should be ended	21%	9%	54%	72%	7%
Columbus Day is too disruptive and expensive to provide police protection and should be ended	31%	16%	42%	61%	9%
Columbus Day should be changed to a different celebration, such as the heritage of all immigrants	40%	23%	37%	49%	10%
Question:    Last Saturday the annual Columbus Day parade was held in downtown Denver.  The annual parade has attracted protesters for many years.  Similar to the Saturday event, there have been confrontations that become disruptive of the parade and arrests are made by the Denver police.  As I read the following statements, please tell me which ones you strongly agree, somewhat agree, somewhat disagree or strongly disagree with.  [Rotated] Note: Total agree and disagree columns combine somewhat and strong categories.  Also, the table shows strong agreement and strong disagreement in separate columns.  Ciruli Associates, N504, 2007

Two additional questions were asked concerning the protests:  one on the costs associated with police protection and another on changing the celebration to an “all immigrants” day.  By two-to-one, voters rejected the protesters’ strategy of disrupting the parade as a method to end it.  There was some sentiment to transforming the celebration to another type of event, such as honoring all of the country’s immigrants (40% agreed; 49% disagreed).

Although Republicans are 20 to 30 percentage points more supportive of the right to have the Columbus Day celebration and opposed to it being forced to end, neither Democrats nor unaffiliated voters support ending the celebration.

Men and women show no difference on the issue beyond the margin of error.

About one-quarter of minority voters favor ending or changing the event to an “all immigrants” celebration.  But a similar percentage oppose those alternatives.

Responses by Gender, Party and Ethnicity Concerning Celebrating Columbus Day
		Keep Event*		It’s Racist/ End*		Too Expensive/ End*		Change Event*
Demographic Characteristics	%	Strongly Agree	Strongly Disagree	Strongly Agree	Strongly Disagree	Strongly Agree	Strongly Disagree	Strongly Agree	Strongly Disagree
Total	100%	50%	10%	9%	54%	16%	42%	23%	37%
Male	50%	52%	8%	9%	56%	14%	45%	20%	39%
Female	50%	48%	13%	9%	52%	17%	38%	25%	36%
Republican	23%	68%	6%	3%	77%	6%	64%	12%	58%
Unaffiliated	18%	46%	12%	8%	47%	15%	38%	21%	38%
Democrat	59%	44%	12%	12%	47%	20%	34%	27%	29%
White	77%	52%	9%	6%	56%	14%	44%	20%	40%
Hispanic	10%	42%	15%	29%	40%	25%	27%	31%	25%
Black	8%	40%	13%	13%	50%	26%	32%	37%	16%
Ciruli Associates, N504, 2007

*Four questions correspond to those shown on the previous table.  Columns report strong agreement and disagreement with the statement.

The question was included in a survey sponsored by the Better Denver Campaign and conducted Oct. 9 to 10, 2007 by Ciruli Associates.  A random sample of 504 Denver voters was interviewed with a margin of error of plus or minus 4.4 percentage points.

. . . . . . . . . . . .

Ciruli Associates is a non-partisan research firm providing polling, election analysis and political commentary to Colorado and national media organizations since 1976.